The Strange, Entertaining, and Sometimes Behind-the-Scenes Story of Cleo Birdwell and Don DeLillo
by Alan Smithee
"Its about a man who turns into a woman Hes the former president of the United States. Hes completed his two terms but hes still very popular and hes always speaking at important banquets. At the same time, hes beginning to turn into a woman. Hes beginning to grow breasts and his genitals are shrinking. He wears a garter belt for the secret thrill it gives him. Hes a WASP, the ex-president. But de new president is black. Hes patterned after Sonny Liston. Hes very hip and magical. He turns on every night and hes making it with all the wives and daughters of the southern senators and even with some of the senators themselves. Itll be over a thousand pages long. Its called Coitus Interruptus. The theme is whatever you want it to be because appearance is all that matters, man. The whole countrys going to puke blood when they read it."
from Americana, by Don DeLillo.
The action picks up in 1997, at the venerable 92nd Street Y. Don DeLillo, chief shaman of the Paranoid School of American Fiction, and one of the most influential writers of the last third of the century, has just completed his first public reading of what some will label his magnum opus, Underworld. As the reclusive author sits at a table, glad-handing with fans and autographing various first editions from his (then) eleven novel oeuvre, a man asks DeLillo to sign a hardback copy of Amazons, An Intimate Memoir by the First Woman Ever to Play in the National Hockey League.
Others in line are confused with good reason. They associate DeLillo with White Noise and Libra and Mao II, tomes that have affected the culture and racked up big awards. Amazons? No ones heard of it. On top of which, looping script identifies its author not as DeLillo but someone named Cleo Birdwell.
DeLillo takes the book. Autographs the title page.
"It's a long story," he says.
In truth, the Behind The Scenes tale of any pseudonym probably should be long, for by its very nature a pseudonym is a vehicle of mystery, an agent of secrets and deception. "When the name is itself secret, the power and influence are magnified," wrote DeLillo, in his appropriately titled novel, The Names. "A secret name is a way of escaping the world. It is an opening into the self." Two books later, in Libra, DeLillos breathtaking imagination of the life and times of Lee Harvey Oswald and the conditions surrounding John Kennedys assassination, the author provided this insight: "History is the sum total of the things they're not telling us." In the same book, he also created, for the fictionalized Oswald, the now-famous mantra: "There is a world within the world." Is there any significance to the fact that DeLillos first novel after taking a pseudonym was called The Names? That Lee Harvey Oswald was buried in a grave under the false name William Bobo? The poet declares that a rose by any other name might smell as sweet, yet a name is nothing if not a personal brand, an associative mantle which bears the cumulative weight of a life. And while under ideal circumstances, a book in particular a novel is a self-contained entity, while any successful piece of writing provides its own justification, acts as its own end and means, it is nonetheless natural that a reader has a certain interest in the life and mind behind the words. Certainly we can be excused for a degree of curiosity when one of our literary bigwigs takes up a mask for the purposes of a volumes creation. Whether the nom de plume is George Eliot, Vivian Calmbrood, Vee Sirin, or Catnab, Robert Markham, Chloe Anthony Wofford, A.N. Roquelaure, the Marquis of Douro, or The Real Slim Shady, let alone an apellation created by the Chief Shaman of The Paranoid School Of American Fiction, inarguably one of the two most influential writers of the last third of a century (donning a figurative bra and panties to write about hockey of all things), in such cases, it does not seen unreasonable to do some extensive and deconstructive line-readings, to solicit gossip and rummage through trash cans; for underneath the cold hard glass of those twin magnifying lenses that are history and fact, we trust and believe that all of the deceptions and secret worlds and silky undergarments will give way, revealing a sliver of the logic between secret and motivation and circumstance, so that an appropriateness and symmetry emerges, and the connections between author and veil start to make sense, and in ways commonsensical and contextual, karmic and inevitable, somehow somehow somehow, this whole strange deal works:
Like how Victorian mores deemed it a crime against church and God for a woman to publish writings; ergo, any decent reading of the bountifully pleasurable, multitextured, and nuanced masterpiece Middlemarch cannot leave a reasonable person surprised at the determination of its author, Marian Evans, who first took the male appellation of George Eliot so that her voice might be heard in a local newspaper column. (Try to imagine, sweet reader, the cosmic awe and relief Eliot/Evans must have felt, after so many years of secret identity, when she opened that now-famous letter from Henry James. Written in appreciation of the Middlemarch, it began: "Dearest madam,").
Or how, as Vladimir Nabokovs literary powers and acumen grew during the authors twenties and thirties, one of the many ways his penchant for mirrors, doppelgangers, and games manifest itself was through alternate identities: Catnab, M. Ageyev, Vladimir Sirin, and the anagram Vivian Calmbrood, were all guises under which the genteel lepidopterist wrote poetry, translations, short dramas, a novel (Novel with Cocaine), and most often veiled attacks on those who had dared attack his own writings.
Even the commonsensical stance of genre novelists Stephen King and Anne Rice has a certain neatness. On the one hand, the Waldenbooks superstars felt a need to branch out beyond the styles and interests which had made them famous. On the other, the commercial guidelines which all but demand they maintain and protect whatever, ahem, integrity their "brand" names have to offer. What better answer than nom de guars (Richard Bachman and A. N. Roquelaure, respectively)?
°Then theres the whole David Foster Wallace/porn thing.
Maybe the answer comes from DeLillo himself, given in a1988 interview with Anthony DeCurtis for Rolling Stone:
Q: The Kennedy assassination seems perfectly in line with the concerns of your fiction. Do you feel you could have invented it if it hadn't happened?
A: Maybe it invented me.
Fall, 1980. Amazons, An Intimate Memoir by the First Woman Ever to Play in the National Hockey League (ISBN# 0-03-055426-8) is published by Holt Reinhart and Winston in simultaneous American and Canadian editions. Although no female has spent one second on the roster of a professional hockey team, on the memoirs back cover, author Cleo Birdwell appears as a delicate, supermodel-y member of the fairer sex. Her flowing blonde hair covers the first and last letters of her hockey jersey, turning Rangers, the nickname of New York Citys hockey team, into the French word for angel. Birdwell, a twenty-three year-old from Beaver, Ohio, claims to have worked her way up through six seasons of minor league stick, and chronicles her inaugural season playing for the Rangers, wherein she became both star and target. "Everyone said I made a blazing entry into the NHL," reads the books third paragraph. "They wrote about my honey blonde hair flying in the breeze, my silver skate blades flashing, my milky blue eyes, my taut ass and firm breasts, the downy white bruises on my milky white thighs."
Infectious, intelligent, and butter-smooth, Amazons slight narrative is held up by the framework of a hockey seasons timeline: Birdwell signs a contract to play for the Rangers, travels with and stars on the team, and then after the playoffs, the fun ends a progression that happens moment-to-moment, almost in matters of happenstance and chance, with the author tagging along as an afterthought, as if to see where things will take her.
"Things kept happening. It was hard for me to find a shape for them. It is still hard. Events and people kept crowding the page. It is like a two-dimensional Japanese subway.
"I thought this would be a little book of meditations. All along Id planned to use Wadi Assads slim volumes as guides and inspirations. I didnt exactly want to be pithy. I know I dont have the discipline for that. But now and then Id like to develop a theme or find a shape for events. I didnt think major thematic material would be this hard to turn up."
"When I was ten, I never went anywhere in Badger without my copy of The American Girl Book of Sports Stories. My mother used to ask me to find a theme in every story, and with a little prodding I could do it. Those stories had themes, every one last one of them. The events were shaped.
"That was Badger. This was Philadelphia, and the Spectrum was full of white-eyed, shining savages."
Along our happenstance wanderings, the reader meets Birdwells agent, Floss Penrose, whose existence depends on playing strip Monopoly with tennis player Archie Brewster ("It is like incest," explains Penrose, "but better."); Madison Square Garden president James Kinross ("Tell you the truth, Birdwell, I hate hockey."); Rangers general manager Sanders Meade (Yale, class of 67, rendered impotent by mentioning the name of a certain well-endowed hockey player, as well as any mention of Watergate, Vietnam, and/or the Iran hostages); and the closest thing Cleo has to a boyfriend one-time hockey player Shaver Stevens, who suffers from a disease called Flying Dutchman, where he intermittently breaks into small annoying mannerisms, checking the bottoms of his shoes and doing deep-knee bends.
Cleo wears white skates and speaks Latin. Her brother is a porn star. The hockey teams radio play-by-play announcer is plagued by a swimming-pool-shaped kidney. Cleo has sex with the tennis player. With the Flying Dutchman disease guy. With the Rangers French-speaking coach. She would have sex with the general manager, except she mentions Watergate and he loses his erection. Everyone mildly associated with the hockey team carries self-help books by the guru Wadi Assad. Cleo bangs just about all of them, the men anyhow. Feeling a certain Seventies vibe yet? How about when we report that her buildings doorman is named Washington Post? That the New York Rangers are purchased by Saudi Arabians? (They demand Cleo wear a veil while playing hockey. She answers: "In the team colors, or strictly black? Is my veil washed with the other players uniforms or is it sent out to a Moslem laundry? Do I have a home veil and a road veil? How do I communicate with my teammates in the heat of battle? Muffled shouts? Eye blinks?") In point of fact, the immediate instinct is to categorize Amazons as a satire of or a very funny reflection on the lives and styles of swingin America at the end of the Disco Decade. Similarly, as Cleo shows herself to be a bright, strong, and beautiful woman, who possesses no sexual hang-ups and bangs whomever she feels like banging, it should be no shock if more than a few fuzzy-lipped womens studies professors claim Amazons as something of a feminist tract. Your correspondent begs to differ. On both points.
While Amazons contains many fine yuks and trenchant observations, the Seventies humor is basically referential, and the book possesses no grand or overriding concerns, be it with the Seventies or anything else; thus the categorization of Amazons as serious satire is erroneous. Moreover, with all due respect to the goddess of the moon and her followers, your correspondent insists, nay, demands that any possible appropriation of Amazons by feminists be given a big fat middle finger, and does this by citing the good book itself, page 335: "A penis erect can be impressive. It has the force of legend and myth. An engorged, murky thing. It loses its playfulness, erect. There is sometimes a purpling along the seams. It is a little beastly if the truth be known. But women accept it as a force of nature and myth that it is. I dont think we want to change the basic principle."
Indeed. Taking into account Cleos intelligence, looks, carnal appetite, and her respect for the force of nature and myth that is an erect penis, it should be fairly obvious that Ms. Birdwell is nothing so much as the product of male imagination, some sort of fantasized ubergal a gentler, smarter cousin to Terry Southern and Mason Hoffenbergs Candy. Likewise, even without the anecdote that worked as this essays lead, any adroit bibliophile should be able to mark her the product of one specific male imagination. The passion for the perfect line, the clean and swift economy of text, the rapid-fire pace of those commas and quips, and the extended set pieces and slapstick-ish conversations... we recognize these. And other similarities abound, most importantly, recognizable as an autograph or thumbprint, is the authors style and process. Admittedly, this sounds fairly esoteric and presumptuous; which is why the following example is offered. In Amazons, a television talk-show doctor famed for his belief that "We dont really know what disease is," convinces Shaver Stevens that the best chance to beat Flying Dutchmans disease involves undergoing five months of suspended animation in something called a Kramer cube. But once Stevens is inside the cube, Cleo does not want to let him out. ("He looks so haunted," she says, admiringly). Moreover, her agent, Floss Penrose decides that she wants her own guy in a Kramer cube. Who cannot see the embryonic similarity between Shavers limbo and the fully-evolved Beckett-inspired monster which, in four years, will envelope Libras FBI agent Nicholas Branch assigned to a basement office, Branch catalogues and archives information on the Kennedy assassination (blacked out and edited files, descriptions of eyewitness dreams following the assassination, reports whose key information was purposefully being kept from him by his superiors, a conflicting and contrary and just plain overwhelming avalanche of facts and fictions). How about the similarities between Branch and professor of Hitler studies, Jack Gladney, who at the end of White Noise is infected with the fallout of the radioactive cloud, and lives each day while death spreads inside of him, with no idea of how much damage has been done, how much time he has left? Nor let us forget novelist Bill Gray from Mao II, in his study, alone, left to perpetually edit and revise his already perfect manuscript.
And then weve got Murray Jay Siskind.
Yes, Murray. You know him at least if you are any sort of DeLillo fan or contemporary bibliophile, you do (if youre not: hi mom & dad J ). For Murrays role in White Noise, the Siskind name holds a place in all of our hearts. At that novels College-on-the-Hill, Siskind, an ex-sportswriter and visiting professor waxes rhapsodic on the sign announcing the most photographed barn in America, and also participates in a tete-a-tete with Jack Gladney concerning the similarities between Elvis and Hitler, a pair of scenes which are now often cited in essays and reprinted in postmodern anthologies and generally get mentioned as ground zero points in the earthquake of self-consciousness which has consumed and shaken our culture, so much so that were all sick of irony and self-consciousness, yet still cannot help being ironic and self-conscious. However dearest reader, did you know that five years before he was a supporting character in White Noise, Murray was a supporting character in Amazons? Well guess what. White Noises visiting professor and ex-sportswriter was a sportswriter he covered Cleo on the Rangers, and lugged around an eight-hundred page manuscript-in-progress (subject: the Mafias control and manipulation of the snowmobile industry. In fact, in Amazons most hilarious and poignant scene, Cleo and Murray have sex, and our heroine uses descriptions of the Christmas rituals in her hometown to arouse him, and the same interest in Americana and popular culture which will so excite Mur in White Noise erupt in a different sort of way.
Talk about your
worlds within worlds.
The straight deal: as the 1970s came to a close, DeLillo was the author of five novels, including the minor wonder Great Jones Street, and a play (The Day Room). He was about to enter an eleven-year run where he would publish, in succession, The Names, White Noise, Libra, and Mao II, books whose individual and collective effect would cement his place in the annals of American Letters. Be it coincidence, sheer dumb luck, or part of some greater cosmic force, while those major works were either still in progress or bubbling on the back-burner of DeLillos subconscious, he finished and sold Amazons.
Independent and anonymous sources have confirmed that DeLillos original intent had been to publish Amazons as his own fiction, only Knopf, his publishing house at the time did not want the novel. An editor at Holt Reinhart Winston then agreed to publish the book pseudonymously, an act which got DeLillo paid, did not affect his contract and relationship with Knopf, and also made for good yuks. We do not know the extent and proportions to which DeLillo, his agent, and the good people at Holt Reinhart Winston were involved in what happened next, nor do we care to speculate how much of a role each played, or whether DeLillo was the jokes instigator, the point man, or simply an amused bystander. What we can say is this: once borne, the idea gained both momentum and participant. For it was not before the considerable weight of the publishing house was fully behind the joke, and uncorrected advance proofs of Amazons went out to reviewers with the following notation : "Unfortunately the author will not be able to tour because she will be leading the Rangers in their pursuit of the 1980-1981 Stanley Cup." Soonafter, a miss Cleo Birdwell appeared on the floor of the 1980 American Booksellers Associations convention in Chicago, IL. Hired out of the Charlize Theron/Cameron Diaz School of Leggy Blonde Models, she not only entertained prospective booksellers and retailers, but also handed out glossy promotional photos, reproduced from the books back cover, of herself, seductively attired in full pads and a Rangers jersey.
The hoax was effectively outed on September 16, 1980. "Cleo Birdwell has a way with the incongruous," wrote New York Times book reviewer Christopher Lehmann-Haupt, "which doesnt come as a surprise once youve learned that her name is the nom de plume for the novelist Don DeLillo." One month later, in The Nation, J.D. OHara provided back-up: "Intuition reports that there are only two men alive capable of writing this book in English, and one of them didnt. So it must be work of that terrific Athenian-American novelist Don DeLillo." Both reviews all but glowed: "One wants to read the whole novel to friends, even on the telephone, collect," declared OHara. "Order by the case. Christmas is coming." Yet glowing reviews and a funny and publicized hoax were not enough to keep Amazons on our literary and cultural scene. The fictional memoir had no second printing. It was reissued in paperback years later, through a small press, but both editions are long out of print. Rarely is Amazons mentioned as part of the Don DeLillo stable, or for any other reason. We had a conversation with a professor of writing from a major eastern university expressively for this subject. Professors eyes clouded. He nodded slightly. Oh right Something about hockey. What was it again?
When one considers that most MFA grads have read, at best, three of DeLillos works (mainlined and memorized White Noise, a gallant attempt at Underworld, purchased and maybe cracked Mao II or Great Jones Street), it seems somewhat appropriate that Amazons has been relegated to the obscure netherspaces of the internet. Birdwell and DeLillo are hyperlinked on web pages specializing in out-of-print editions and rare books; searching four such pages uncovered nineteen available copies (at prices ranging from $40-150), as well as on Amazon.com three customer reviews; although, in truth, those didnt help so much, seeing that two reviewers professed the belief that Birdwell was indeed a woman, and one went so far as to recommend Amazons "to any adult females interested in playing professional hockey."
And here your correspondent would like to say something.
It is my humble belief that a difference exists between the writers Cleo Birdwell and Don DeLillo. I propose that this difference is significant. It is important. Cleo Birdwell may be quite charming when she ends consecutive chapters with sex scenes, and then promises to find some other way to end a chapter. Her author photo is hot as hell. But I am not convinced that the narrators search for direction and structure necessarily flies as a larger thematic search for direction and structure. Ultimately, Amazons is a hilarious string of gags, a quick and fun read; a fine, if minor novel.
By comparison, consider the oft-repeated tale of Underworlds genesis.
DeLillo was spinning through old New York Times microfiche when he came upon a 1951 front page with neighboring headlines. One announced the first Russian testing of a nuclear bomb. The other: Bobby Thompsons famous Shot Heard Round The World home-run.
"You suddenly hit upon something and you realize this is the path you were meant to take," DeLillo told Melody Maker, in 1988 (an interview conducted for the release of Libra). "You'd be a fool if you didn't follow it. Perhaps it's like solving a difficult question in pure mathematics. There must be a moment when the solution is so simple and evident that you wonder why you hadn't come upon it before. When you do come upon it, you know it in the deepest part of your being. It carries its own logic."
For your contemplation and approval, it is here submitted that Don DeLillo runs neck and neck with Thomas Pynchon in the race for Writer of Our Age and Place in no small part because of the narrative juxtapositions and creative tensions which shape and inform his novels, providing their scope and scale. In End Zone it was football and nuclear weapons. In Great Jones Street, rock and roll and urban nihilism. The Names saw a triangulation between language, how Americans view themselves in foreign lands, and how people of foreign lands view Americans. Mao II directly links writing and terrorism. And then theres the masterworks: White Noise, where DeLillo did nothing so much as mold a novel around the connection between conspicuous consumption, commercial popular culture, and the contemporary American fear of death; Libra II, where he literally traced the moment in history when all the fringe and bizarre strands along the edges combined and unraveled the American flag; and, finally, Underworld, where he simultaneously tackled all of these things:
"It's no accident that my first novel was called Americana. This was a private declaration of independence, a statement of my intention to use the whole picture, the whole culture. America was and is the immigrant's dream, and as the son of two immigrants I was attracted by the sense of possibility that had drawn my grandparents and parents."
DeLillo, from a 1993 interview with Adam Begley
Since the first sentence of his first novel "Then we came to the end of another dull and lurid year," DeLillos subject has been nothing less than the myth of America The Beautiful, not only the pathos of our country in the wake of World War II as it shoulders the burden and mantle of Leader of the Free World, but the very sense of possibility which has become inherent with this burden, and the full circle of dreams and disappointments and ramifications that such burdens and possibilities bring at both the societal, and the individual levels. He has provided the reader with large and sweeping arcs as well as the characters who must exist underneath such a shelter and shadow, not only all of the internal pressures that come with being part of the biggest baddest planet saving nation, but the sad and larger realization that the biggest and baddest nation is incapable of saving itself. Feeding into and emerging from this foreboding and heavy, yet still glittering air, hope is tinged with dread, humorous lines gain gravity and become more than jokes, allowing us to read on, captive, a bit too familiar with the sense of contentment, creeping dread, and self-hatred which grows and spreads through the last half of Twentieth Century America,finally transforming irony from underground black humor into a national currency, cynicism into the prevalent assumptions. The Great Jones Street rock star who answers every hippyish exit line of "peace" by saying, "war." The hilarious and somewhat sad and frightening question and answer sessions among White Noise professors of pop culture ("Did you ever spit in your soda bottle so you wouldnt have to share your drink with other kids?" "How old were you when you first realized your father was a jerk?" "Do you ever close your eyes while youre driving on a highway?"). Think of the narrator in The Names and his reasons for refusing to visit the Parthenon: "It looms. Its so powerfully there. It almost forces us to ignore it. Or at least to resist it. We have our self-importance. We also have our inadequacy. The former is a desperate invention of the latter." And also think of Mao II, the novelist Bill Greys comments to the men who would kidnap him: "Do you know why I believe in the novel? Its a democratic shout. Anyone can write a great novel, one great novel, almost any amateur off the street Some nameless drudge, some desperado with barely a nurtured dream can sit down and find his voice and luck out and do it. Something so angelic it makes your jaw hang open."
We get the whole scope. The view from above as provided by a dark angel. In response our jaws can only hang open, allowing forth the rivers of blood.